Palantir is a powerful and secretive company that builds software to help governments and defend Western values. Shyam is a key leader who created the role of Forward Deployed Engineer and helped the company succeed in difficult situations. Though Shyam has recently become more public, there is a tension between genuine warning and strategic business messaging in his new role.
12 highlights
tenuously
Thiel’s kernel insight—that the post-9/11 “security vs. privacy” debate was a false tradeoff that could be broken by software innovation in data engineering,
Shyam says it began with a claim Karp had made one day that French restaurants are good because the wait staff are part of the kitchen staff—rather than merely fulfilling orders and transporting plates, their knowledge of the kitchen’s techniques, methodology, and combinations, he explained, is as intimate as the cooks’. Karp’s point was that he didn’t believe in boffins sequestered in a lab polishing their Platonic ideal of a product; he wanted them to go figure out what customers actually wanted, build it, and show evidence that they loved it.
They end up realizing they need AI infrastructure, and now they’re on a 10-year journey to build something we already built.
According to Tampa General, Foundry saved several hundred patients from septic shock during the COVID Delta wave of 2021, when Palantir also reportedly played a role in helping the U.S. and UK governments distribute vaccines.
borborygmus
A continuously updating map of a notional battlespace in Ukraine showed Russian and Ukrainian unit positions, orders of battle, trench lines, and 48-hour fire patterns. Each of these, I was told, is continuously pulled from human and electronic intelligence, overhead sensor detection of flashes on the ground, satellite imagery, and computer vision detection of grid coordinates gleaned from social media posts. When asked a ridiculous question like “How many U.S. Army Black Hawk pilots speak fluent Hungarian and are available to deploy to Korea tomorrow?”, the system generates an immediate answer. When asked to generate a strike package, the system’s AI layer does so in about 30 seconds, including by listing the available assets in each service branch, calculating time-on-station, and coordinating air defense suppression with the ensuing bomber waves
I asked whether these tools should nevertheless not exist, knowing that human nature is forked, politics are fallen, and people in positions of power over others will find ways to abuse it, regardless of technical controls. “That’s just crazy to me,” he replied. “We should expect our institutions to operate really well. They serve the citizen at the end of the day, and you know, it’s not okay that doors fall off planes. It’s not okay that Intel was almost run into the ground because we cared more about financial engineering than actual engineering. These things speak to our national security and prosperity. Why would we indulge in this nihilistic managerialism that’s just ruining everything? And then extend that to government: Are the American people sure that the military we have is the military we need and expect? Of course these things need to work.
monopsony
The tension in Shyam’s newfound participation in these media is not any insincerity, but a certain self-awareness, almost palpable through the screen, of the trap it lays—of a concern that we won’t be able to distinguish between genuine warnings about the entropy of the universe and a rhetorically sophisticated strategy for business development; an awareness of the reason that prophets have not historically been chief executives of publicly traded companies.
It’s the primacy of winning, defeating nihilism and cynicism. You can’t achieve American Greatness through zero-sum divisiveness.
Dynamic typing is but a special case of static typing,
To borrow an apt description from Dana Scott, the so-called untyped (that is “dynamically typed”) languages are, in fact*,* unityped. Rather than have a variety of types from which to choose, there is but one!
Even if in a particular situation we are absolutely certain that a particular value is, say, an integer, we have no choice but to regard it as a value of the “one true type” that is classified, not typed, as an integer.
you are depriving yourself of the ability to state and enforce the invariant that the value at a particular program point must be an integer
The goal of (static, there is no other kind) type systems is precisely to provide the expressive power to capture all computational phenonema, including dynamic dispatch and dynamically extensible classification, within the rich framework of a static type discipline.
I spent some time looking at how to implement it manually, and came away from it with the understanding that I’d have to maintain separate implementations for Windows and Unix. Not only that, I’d just be duplicating a lot of the work Tokio had already done to abstract over platform differences. So I started looking at porting over nextest to Tokio.