Gazette

Vol. 27 Sunday, 20 July 2025
Vol. 27 20 Jul 2025

The concept of a "social contract" in taxation describes the relationship between citizens and the state, where taxpayers expect public services in return for their contributions. However, this framework can favor the wealthy, as it ties benefits to what individuals can give, potentially undermining progressive taxation. Advocates for fair taxation should clarify their vision of a social contract as a fair agreement among all citizens, emphasizing equality and justice.

5 highlights

If tax is about putting resources into the pot in exchange for services, poor and lower income groups with less to give are also not able to get very much out. At the same time, the rich can justify demanding policies that benefit them in exchange for their larger contributions. Some research suggests this is exactly what happens in modern states: states that tax lower income residents more tend to provide more social services, while those that rely more heavily on taxing the rich provide more property protection.

The surprising thing about this conclusion is that it is at odds with a powerful tradition in moral and political philosophy that emphasizes social contracts as a foundation for justice.

But there are risks when we treat this positive concept (that is, a concept that describes how the world is) as a normative concept (that is, as a guide to how the world should be).

“An important part of every country’s development process is the building of a social contract in which citizens pay tax and, in turn, receive public goods and services.”

the social contract is not between citizens and the state. It is rather among citizens to create the state. In other words, the very nature of the contract is one between free persons in some “state of nature,” before the state exists, and not between an existing institution and “taxpayers.”

  • The Gene: An Intimate History #
    , 5 highlights

    The movement of genetic information from one chromosome to another occurs only under extremely special circumstances. The first occurs when sperm and eggs are generated for reproduction. Just before the spermiogenesis and oogenesis, the cell turns briefly into a playpen for genes. The paired maternal and paternal chromosomes hug each other and readily swap genetic information. The swapping of genetic information between paired chromosomes is crucial to the mixing and matching of hereditary information between parents. Morgan called this phenomenon crossing over (his students had used crossing over to map genes in flies). The more contemporary term is recombination—the ability to generate combinations of combinations of genes.

    Regulation. Replication. Recombination. Remarkably, the three R’s of gene physiology

    The fact that the genome also encodes genes to repair damage to the genome was discovered by several geneticists, including Evelyn Witkin and Steve Elledge. Witkin and Elledge, working independently, identified an entire cascade of proteins that sensed DNA damage, and activated a cellular response to repair or temporize the damage (if the damage was catastrophic, it would halt cell division). Mutations in these genes can lead to the accumulation of DNA damage—and thus, more mutations—ultimately leading to cancer. The fourth R of gene physiology, essential to both the survival and mutability of organisms, might be “repair.”

    Mutations in genes that specified the basic elements of the body plan were more difficult to identify, since the mutations sharply decreased the survival of organisms. And mutants in the very first steps of embryogenesis were nearly impossible to capture alive since the embryos, with scrambled heads and tails, died instantly.

    (the direct transmission of an adaptation into a heritable feature, remember, was the basis for Lamarck’s flawed theory of evolution by adaptation).

  • Laura Deming: ‘I wanted to work on the world’s most important problem’ #
    , 1 highlight

    She wants to increase people’s “health span” — the number of healthy years of life — rather than aim at immortality.