Gazette

Vol. 24 Sunday, 29 June 2025
Vol. 24 29 Jun 2025

The Ames test, developed by Bruce N. Ames in 1973, is a method for identifying chemical carcinogens using mutant strains of Salmonella. It showed that many natural substances could be just as mutagenic as synthetic chemicals, challenging the belief that cancer was primarily caused by artificial substances. This test has influenced discussions about cancer risks and regulation in both scientific and political contexts.

18 highlights

e four Salmonella strains were further customized with additional genetic changes that made the cells more permeable to large molecules and eliminated some kinds of DNA repair.

Facilitating the adoption of his test method, Ames made his strains freely available. Environmental groups were equally enthusiastic about the test, particularly once Ames identifi ed as likely carcinogens a food preservative and a fl ame retardant being incorporated into children’s pajamas.

First, as Ames put it, a carcinogen is a mutagen. Human cancer, in this view, could be triggered by exposure to environmental mutagens.1 Compounds that do not induce mutations were presumed not to cause cancer, either. Second, he assumed that a microbe was a suitable model organism for assaying mutagenicity as it occurred in human cells.

the broader context of postwar radiation genetics and environmentalism

Ames and his coworkers suggested that histidine regulated its own biosynthesis at the gene level, by repressing “the synthesis of all of the biosynthetic enzymes together”

It was not only scientists who were concerned, of course: Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring, which appeared in 1962, built on the public fear of radioactive contamination generated by the fallout debates to draw attention to the unseen hazards of pesticides and other synthetic chemicals (Lutts 1985).

In addition, all four tester strains included a mutation in the uvrB gene that disabled DNA excision repair, making them more sensitive to mutagens whose eff ects would otherwise be corrected by this system.

ree of the strains (originally TA1531, TA1532, and TA1534) were designed to detect diff erent kinds of frameshift mutagens. Th e fourth strain, TA1530, contained a base-pair change, and so it would detect mutations that involve base-pair substitutions.

Ames’s group showed that spreading an extract of rat or human liver with the potential carcinogen on the petri dish allowed testing of metabolic derivatives of the compound being tested (Ames et al. 1973). It was known that mammalian microsomal hydroxylase activated many classes of carcinogens and mutagens, including afl atoxin, aromatic amines, and polycyclic hydrocarbons (Ames 1973: 116).

Szybalski noted a strong correlation between carcinogenicity and mutagenicity: “these studies demonstrated a close correlation between the carcinogenic eff ect in mammals and the mutagenic eff ect on bacteria, stimulating a wide interest in this fi eld”

In addition, companies such as DuPont and American Cyanamid used it to test new products before deciding whether to bring them to market. According to Ames, DuPont decided not to produce two Freon propellants because they were found to be mutagenic in Salmonella tests

Sugimura found that plants were a major source of mutagens

He also pointed out that in both number and amount, we ingested more “natural pesticides and other natural toxic molecules (and traditional mixtures such as cooked food) than we do of manmade substances”

geneticists tended to view chemical mutagens as inherently different from radiation, which could directly modify genes. Demerec asserted that chemical agents induced mutations in an indirect way—that “mutagenic treatment brings about some change in either cytoplasm or nucleus which in turn aff ects certain physiological processes of the cell, and thereby infl uences genes”

scientists increasingly took the well-established correlation between mutagenicity and carcinogenicity as causal rather than coincidental

the apparent alliance between molecular biologists and environmental organizations was already unraveling in the late 1970s over disagreements about the safety of recombinant DNA.

"The effort to prove a big role for industrial chemicals diverts attention from what is probably the best hope for reducing cancer incidence—careful study of foods and effects of cooking. … All people ingest the mutagens and carcinogens of food daily"

Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway