Gazette

Vol. 21 Sunday, 8 June 2025
Vol. 21 8 Jun 2025

The Linear No Threshold (LNT) model suggests that any amount of radiation increases cancer risk, leading to strict safety regulations that make nuclear power expensive. This theory, initially based on studies of fruit flies and influenced by political agendas, is now being questioned by some scientists. New research indicates that there may be thresholds for radiation harm, challenging long-held beliefs about its risks.

11 highlights

‘Linear No Threshold’ (or LNT). LNT is the hypothesis that the relationship between radiation dose and cancer risk to humans is linear and that there is no truly ‘safe’ level of radiation.

the hypothesis holds that any amount of ionizing radiation increases cancer risk, and that the harm is cumulative, meaning that multiple small doses over time carry the same risk as a single large dose of the same total magnitude.

In 1930, Muller had observed that ‘the frequency of mutations produced is exactly proportional to the energy of the dosage absorbed’,

modern cytogenetics, the study of chromosomes.

ALARA – the goal of reducing background radiation from nuclear reactors to a level ‘as low as reasonably achievable’ – were sown. The principle combines the Linear No Threshold view that all ionizing radiation causes harm to humans with the view that it is never worth trading off some health costs against other benefits.

Muller was awarded the 1946 Nobel Prize in Medicine.

If the human body has ways of healing itself, then lower doses over a sustained period of time seem unlikely to have the same effect as the same size dose taken at once. The body will use the time to repair the damage caused by the low doses that it does not have when it experiences the high dose.

Scientists who believe in the existence of a safe threshold have the unenviable task of essentially proving a negative, definitively showing that no effect exists below a certain dose. Meanwhile, LNT advocates have a simple model that can always be defended using the precautionary principle.

These practical challenges make LNT borderline unfalsifiable. Whether its statistical limitations, the challenge of controlling for other factors, or difficulties in follow-up, it will always be possible to find a reason to dismiss any single study that contradicts it.

Meanwhile, the costs of ALARA only continue to stack up. The case of the banana-like levels of radiation exposure is just one example. Tens of billions of dollars are added to the lifetime costs of nuclear projects to bury waste underground in deep geological repositories, facilities 200 to 1,000 metres below the surface of the earth, on safety grounds. There have been no fatalities in the history of international nuclear energy waste management.

Linear No Threshold

  • Do Cellphones Cause Brain Cancer? #
    , 8 highlights

    When a rare form of cancer is associated with a rare exposure, the link between the risk and the cancer stands out starkly.

    a common exposure is associated with a common form of cancer

    a common exposure is associated with a rare form of cancer.

    Several cancers are strongly, often exponentially, age-dependent. An aging population will seem more cancer-afflicted, even if the real cancer incidence has not changed.

    In the late 1940s, Sir Richard Doll and Sir Austin Bradford Hill, working in London, and Ernst Wynder and Evarts Graham, working in St. Louis, began investigating whether tobacco smoking increased the risk of lung cancer.

    What if you perform a similar case-control study with cellphones — comparing men and women suffering from brain cancer (cases) and men and women without brain cancer (controls) — looking at their past cellphone use? In 2010, an enormous study, called Interphone, tried to accomplish this task.

    The trouble is that even the largest, longest, best-designed retrospective studies that rely on memory are likely to be riddled by recall bias.

    Radiation from microwaves, from cellular phones and from light bulbs are examples of nonionizing radiation.

  • The Fine-Tuning Argument Simply Works #
    , 3 highlights

    Pauli exclusion principle

    The nomological fine-tuning argument, then, is the conceptual argument that it’s very difficult to produce a physical system that produces anything interesting or valuable.

    Call sets of laws fragile if changing them slightly would make it impossible for life to arise and nonfragile if they could be changed a lot. Proponents of this objection claim that our laws are fragile but there are vast islands of non-fragile laws in possibility space, making the probability of life-permitting laws not terribly low. Note that for this objection to work, there have to mostly be nonfragile laws—if they’re mostly fragile then that means that for every life-permitting laws, there are many that aren’t life-permitting.

    But if most laws are nonfragile, then it’s inexplicable that our laws our fragile. Precisely as one ratchets up the share of life-permitting laws that aren’t fragile, by the same amount that they raise the probability of life-permitting laws existing at all, they lower the probability of having laws like ours, conditional on having life-permitting laws.

    Making there be more laws different from ours may raise the odds that life-permitting laws would exist in the first place, but they don’t affect the odds of our life-permitting laws arising one bit!

    So this objection isn’t just wrong about the physics, it’s wrong probabilistically. It also fails to deal with the nomological fine-tuning point, that laws capable of sustaining life are inherently rare. It’s hard to make a system that produces anything interesting!

  • Capturing and Colliding #
    , 2 highlights

    “commonplacing,” as it was called, involved transcribing interesting or inspirational passages from one’s reading, assembling a personalized encyclopedia of quotations.

    I like to read two or three books concurrently—though one of them is usually a novel—precisely because I’m more likely to stumble up an interesting connection if I’ve just switched from one book to another, for the simple reason the ideas in book one are still fresh in my memory when I switch over to book two. (This is the argument for taking “reading sabbaticals”—made famous by Bill Gates—where you lock yourself up for two weeks and do nothing but read.)

  • Tegmark's Mathematical Universe Defeats Most Proofs Of God's Existence #
    , 2 highlights

    Consider a mathematical object like a cellular automaton - a set of simple rules that creates complex behavior. The most famous is Conway’s Game of Life; the second most famous is the universe. After all, the universe is a starting condition (the Big Bang) and a set of simple rules determining how the starting condition evolves over time (the laws of physics).

    Tegmark’s hypothesis says: all possible mathematical objects exist.